Monday, November 9, 2015

Why Do You Live Where You Do?

http://www.citylab.com/housing/2015/2015/why-people-live-where-they-do/414873/?utm_source+nl_link1_110915



Random blue door to a house
Ikpro/Shutterstock.com
citylab.com
Hello Everyone:

A new week and new subjects to write about.

Have you ever considered why you live where you do?  There are the obvious reasons: work, school, family but could there be any other reason why you chose to live in one place over another.  Like Richard Florida, the author of today's article "Why People Live Where They Do" for CityLab, yours truly firmly believes that where you choose to live is the single most important decision you make.  A new report from the Centre for Cities (http://www.centreforcities.org), a London-based research and policy institute takes a detailed look at the this question.

House in Putney, South London, England
rightmove.co.uk
Richard Florida writes, "It uses comprehensive survey data from urban areas across Great Britain to examine what urbanites and suburbanites value the most (and like the least) about the neighborhood they live in, including...housing costs, proximity to jobs, transit, amenities, open space, and quality of both built and natural environment."  The report uses two YouGov (http://www.yougov.com) surveys: a national poll of more than 2,000 people from 59 cities in Great Britain and a more specific poll of 1,725 in Brighton, Manchester, Sheffield, and Swindon.


"The main reason why respondents chose to live in their
neighbourhoods by age"
YouGov, 2015
citylab.com
What matters most

No surprise, the main things that matter to people about the neighborhood they chose to live include such issues as housing costs, proximity to family and place of employment.  Housing costs and nearness to friends was important to 28 percent of those surveyed, this was followed by size and type of available housing (22 percent), and closeness to their or their parents's workplace (21 percent).

Richard Florida has long argued that people make three big moves in their lives: in our mid-twenties following graduation and begin their careers (the age he says, "most likely to move"), when we start our families, and when the children leave the nest.  The figure on the left is a breakdown, by age, why people chose to live where they do.

For college-age people-people 18 to 24-the main reason why they live where they do is the desire to remain in the neighborhood where they grew up.  This is perfectly logical  because many in this age group still live with their parents: specifically, "17 percent said they were studying in the neighborhood."  This reason was followed closely by a need to stay close to friend and family (26 percent), while 17 percent wanted to stay near their job or their partner's place employment (in an aside "which makes sense, as fewer in this age group work").  However, living at home does have its downside.  Beside the lack of autonomy and privacy, the young cohort cited the lack of available public transit (19 percent) and distance from restaurant and entertainment facilities were also cited by 17 percent of the 18 to 24 cohort as a negative of living at home.

Manchester skyline
Manchester, England
layoverguide.com
Individuals between 25-34 years of age-the cohort most likely to move to start their careers-are more attracted to employment and amenities than the younger cohort.  Almost a third (31 percent) placed a premium on proximity to their or their partner's workplace.  According to Mr. Florida, "This is about the same as those who said they still lived in the neighborhood where they grew up (32 percent), and those for whom the cost of housing (30 percent) was a key factor."  A smaller percentage of this cohort (9 percent) reported "that being  close to restaurants, cultural and leisure facilities are important attributes of where they choose to live."  Specifically, 11 percent placed emphasis on being close to green spaces and 8 percent reported "that the quality of the natural and built environment was a factor.  Nine percent said safety and security was a key factor in their choice of neighborhood."

Peace Gardens and Fountain
Sheffield, England
bound.com
The next age group, 35-54, is the cohort most likely to have families and raise children-place a high value on housing costs (30 percent), size and type of housing (21 percent), safe and security (17 percent), closeness to good schools (13 percent).  The presence of children in the house, 27 percent place a premium on closeness to family and friends.  Finally, after fully entering the working world, 25 percent placed a priority on being close to their job or their partner's employment.  A fifth (20 percent) reported "that being close to green space was important, and another 11 percent valued the quality of the natural and built environment."  However, 4 percent "reported access to restaurant and other cultural amenities as a factor."

Brighton Marina
Brighton, England
en.wikipedia.org
The 55 and over cohort-i.e. the retirees and empty nesters with children out of the house-had different priorities.  Near the top of their list was closeness to green space (30 percent), size and type of residence (29 percent).  Yet, those close to retirement or retired still valued proximity to their workplace or their partner's workplace.  Over a quarter in this cohort (27 percent) reported that proximity to friends and family.  Mr. Florida writes, "Many older parents, after all, value being close to their adult children."  Finally, 17 percent of this group of respondents reported that safety and security was one of their top priorities.

Swindon City Center
Swindon, England
swindonwebcam.com
City versus suburb

Now we turn our attention to why some people prefer the cities to the suburbs.  The questions asked: "What kinds of people prefer these options, and at what ages?  What is it about cities and suburbs that draw people in?"

Richard Florida reports, "The study notes that large cities have the biggest population growth in Britain over the past decade or so."  Specifically, between 2001and 2011 large city center a little more than doubled in population (108 percent), while medium and small centers saw drastically smaller increases in population: 35 and 22 percent respectively.  Students and young people were cited as the primary mechanisms that drove the growth of cities during the study period.  Mr. Florida reports, "...more than half the overall growth from 2001-2011 attributable to an influx of students, and another third attributable to young grads under 35 years old.  In fact by 2011, over a third of British residents in large city centers had a college degree..."  While large city dwellers gravitated to high skilled professions, medium and small city residents tended to work in low skilled jobs, but typically had families and commuted to work in the suburbs.

"The main reasons why respondents chose to live in their neighborhoods"
YouGov, 2015
city lab.com

The chart on the left presents a summary of the key results for three cohorts of urban dwellers, suburbanites, and rural residents.  Urban dwellers placed a higher priority on proximity to restaurant, entertainment and cultural venues, public transportation, shops, and living near their place of employment.  Suburbanites and rural residents placed value on housing costs, the size and type of housing, safety and security, schools, green space, and closeness to friends and family.  These same groups are more likely to live in the neighborhoods where they grew up and were less worried about being close to their place of employments.

Suburbanites and rural residents were also had fewer complaints about where they lived.  They were more likely to cite the lack of access to public transit, distance from entertainment venues and other amenities as the things they least liked about their neighborhoods. Housing costs and distance from friends and family were also cited as the things they least liked about their neighborhoods.

"The least favourite things about the neighborhoods that respondents live in"
YouGov, 2015
citylab.com
The Case of London

London, England is one of the world's leading cities.  In recent years, the capitol city has grown dramatically, pulling in young, talented, and skilled people (in an aside, Mr. Florida writes, "by 2011, 48 percent of its residents had college degrees..."), as well as becoming a destination for the fabulously wealthy.  Simultaneously, the city "has developed a vibrant tech economy to complement its long-established finance and media clusters."  All of these combined factors has created considerable pressure on the housing market.




"The main reasons why Londoners chose to live in their neighborhood"
YouGov, 2015
citylab.com
The chart on the left presents a breakdown of the reasons why Londoners chose to live in the neighborhoods do.  The chief reason given for neighborhood selection was access to public transit.  Richard Florida writes, "This makes sense, given that 90 percent of workers in central London either use public transit or walk or cycle to work and 30 percent of London's jobs are located in its core."  The next factor was the cost of housing in a particular neighborhood.  This was followed by closeness to friends and family, workplace proximity, and surprisingly having been raised in that neighborhood.





Changing priorities

In short, there are those of us how are life long urbanites or suburbanites, but our preferences and priorities can and do change over the course of our lives.  This study demonstrates that while many young people prefer the big cities with all of the amenities it has to offer, older respondents and those with families have a different set of priorities when choosing a place to live.  What this study tell us is "Ultimately we look for cities and neighborhoods that fit us best at the time."  Priorities such as: access to transit, types and size of housing, housing costs, closeness to friends and family, and proximity to work are values across the board.  Despite the fact that our neighborhood preferences may change over time, the things we tend value remain the same. 




No comments:

Post a Comment